Tk Source Code

View Ticket
Login
Ticket UUID: 1719278
Title: select test cases fail
Type: Bug Version: obsolete: 8.5a6, 8.6.18, 9.0.5, 9.1b1
Submitter: lvirden Created on: 2007-05-15 13:14:08
Subsystem: 53. [selection] Assigned To: aku
Priority: 5 Medium Severity: Minor
Status: Closed Last Modified: 2026-11-13 17:57:05
Resolution: Fixed Closed By: nemethi
    Closed on: 2026-11-13 17:57:05
Description:
Platform: sparc solaris 9, latest tcl/tk cvs head, sun compiler, sun gnome desktop, windows xp exceed 10 x server

The following errors are occurring:

==== select-10.1 ConvertSelection procedure, race with selection clear FAILED
==== Contents of test case:

    setup
    proc Ready {fd} {
        variable x
        lappend x [gets $fd]
    }
    set fd [open "|[list [interpreter] -geometry +0+0 -name tktest]" r+]
    puts $fd "puts foo; [loadTkCommand]; flush stdout"
    flush $fd
    gets $fd
    fileevent $fd readable [list Ready $fd]
    set selValue "Just a simple test"
    set selInfo ""
    selection handle .f1 {handler STRING}
    update
    puts $fd {puts "[catch {selection get} msg] $msg"; puts **DONE**; flush stdo
ut}
    flush $fd
    after 200
    selection own .
    set x {}
    vwait [namespace which -variable x]
    puts $fd {exit}
    flush $fd
    # Don't understand why, but the [loadTkCommand] above causes
    # a "broken pipe" error when Tk was actually [load]ed in the child.
    catch {close $fd}
    lappend x $selInfo

---- Result was:
{1 PRIMARY selection doesn't exist or form "STRING" not defined} {STRING 0 4000}
---- Result should have been (exact matching):
{1 PRIMARY selection doesn't exist or form "STRING" not defined} {}
==== select-10.1 FAILED

==== select-10.2 ConvertSelection procedure FAILED
==== Contents of test case:

    setup
    setupbg
    set selValue [string range $longValue 0 3999]
    set selInfo ""
    selection handle .f1 {handler STRING}
    set result ""
    lappend result [dobg {selection get}]
    cleanupbg
    lappend result $selInfo

---- Result was:
Aa.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ba.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Ca.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Da.1a.2a.3a.4a.5
a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ea.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14
Fa.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ga.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Ha.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ia.1a.2a.3a.4a.5
a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ka.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14
La.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ma.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Na.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ab.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Bb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Cb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Db.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10
b.11b.12b.13b.14Eb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Fb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Gb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Hb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Ib.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10
b.11b.12b.13b.14Kb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Lb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Mb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Nb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Ac.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Bc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Cc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Dc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14
Ec.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Fc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Gc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Hc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Ic.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14
Kc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Lc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Mc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Nc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Ad.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Bd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Cd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Dd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Ed.1d.2d.3d.4d.5
d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Fd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Gd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Hd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Id.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Kd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5
d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Ld.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Md.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Nd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Ae.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Be.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ce.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
De.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ee.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10
e.11e.12e.13e.14Fe.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ge.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14He.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
Ie.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ke.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10
e.11e.12e.13e.14Le.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Me.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ne.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
Af.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Bf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Cf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Df.1f.2f.3f.4f.5
f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Ef.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14
Ff.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Gf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Hf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14If.1f.2f.3f.4f.5
f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Kf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14
Lf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Mf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Nf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Ag.1g.2g.3g.4g.5
g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Bg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14
Cg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Dg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10
g.11g.12g.13g.14Eg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Fg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5
 {STRING 0 4000 STRING 4000 4000 STRING 0 4000 STRING 4000 4000 STRING 0 4000 ST
RING 4000 4000 STRING 0 4000 STRING 4000 4000}
---- Result should have been (exact matching):
Aa.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ba.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Ca.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Da.1a.2a.3a.4a.5
a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ea.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14
Fa.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ga.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Ha.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ia.1a.2a.3a.4a.5
a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ka.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14
La.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ma.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10
a.11a.12a.13a.14Na.1a.2a.3a.4a.5a.6a.7a.8a.9a.10a.11a.12a.13a.14Ab.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Bb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Cb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Db.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10
b.11b.12b.13b.14Eb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Fb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Gb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Hb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Ib.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10
b.11b.12b.13b.14Kb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Lb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5
b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Mb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14
Nb.1b.2b.3b.4b.5b.6b.7b.8b.9b.10b.11b.12b.13b.14Ac.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Bc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Cc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Dc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14
Ec.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Fc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Gc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Hc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Ic.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14
Kc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Lc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10
c.11c.12c.13c.14Mc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Nc.1c.2c.3c.4c.5
c.6c.7c.8c.9c.10c.11c.12c.13c.14Ad.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Bd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Cd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Dd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Ed.1d.2d.3d.4d.5
d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Fd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Gd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Hd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Id.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Kd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5
d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Ld.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14
Md.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10d.11d.12d.13d.14Nd.1d.2d.3d.4d.5d.6d.7d.8d.9d.10
d.11d.12d.13d.14Ae.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Be.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ce.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
De.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ee.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10
e.11e.12e.13e.14Fe.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ge.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14He.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
Ie.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ke.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10
e.11e.12e.13e.14Le.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Me.1e.2e.3e.4e.5
e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14Ne.1e.2e.3e.4e.5e.6e.7e.8e.9e.10e.11e.12e.13e.14
Af.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Bf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Cf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Df.1f.2f.3f.4f.5
f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Ef.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14
Ff.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Gf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Hf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14If.1f.2f.3f.4f.5
f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Kf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14
Lf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Mf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10
f.11f.12f.13f.14Nf.1f.2f.3f.4f.5f.6f.7f.8f.9f.10f.11f.12f.13f.14Ag.1g.2g.3g.4g.5
g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Bg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14
Cg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Dg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10
g.11g.12g.13g.14Eg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5g.6g.7g.8g.9g.10g.11g.12g.13g.14Fg.1g.2g.3g.4g.5
 {STRING 0 4000 STRING 4000 4000 STRING 0 4000 STRING 4000 4000}
==== select-10.2 FAILED
==== select-11.1 TkSelPropProc procedure FAILED
==== Contents of test case:

    setup
    setupbg
    set selValue $longValue
    set selInfo ""
    selection handle -type TEST .f1 { handler TEST }
    selection handle -type STRING .f1 { reallyBadHandler .f1 STRING }
    set result ""
    set pass 0
    lappend result [dobg {selection get}]
    cleanupbg
    lappend result $selInfo

---- Result was:
{PRIMARY selection doesn't exist or form "STRING" not defined} {.f1 STRING 0 400
0 .f1 STRING 4000 4000 .f1 STRING 8000 4000 .f1 STRING 12000 4000 .f1 STRING 160
00 4000 .f1 STRING 0 4000 .f1 STRING 4000 4000}
---- Result should have been (exact matching):
{selection owner didn't respond} {.f1 STRING 0 4000 .f1 STRING 4000 4000 .f1 STR
ING 8000 4000 .f1 STRING 12000 4000 .f1 STRING 16000 4000 .f1 STRING 0 4000 .f1 
STRING 4000 4000}
==== select-11.1 FAILED
User Comments: nemethi (claiming to be Csaba Nemethi) added on 2026-11-13 17:57:05:

Serhiy, many thanks! Merged into main, core-9-0-branch, and core-8-6-branch by commits [3ed1deb6], [39821e41], and [81d9bddf].


serhiy.storchaka added on 2026-09-30 11:51:20:

The unexpected STRING 0 4000 in select-10.1 means that the selection handler was called by another client. Exceed makes the X selection available to the Windows clipboard, so it requests the PRIMARY selection as well. The same happens with clipboard managers on Linux; see [610188].

Proposed fix in branch select-tests-private-selection ([29a21fe034]): these tests use a private selection instead of PRIMARY, so that other clients cannot interfere.