Tk Library Source Code

View Ticket
Login
Ticket UUID: 1115865
Title: WebDAV client
Type: RFE Version: None
Submitter: jcw Created on: 2005-02-04 00:45:33
Subsystem: tcllib: request for new module Assigned To: patthoyts
Priority: 5 Medium Severity:
Status: Closed Last Modified: 2013-07-04 17:25:45
Resolution: Not Applicable Here Closed By:
    Closed on:
Description:
There's a new implementation of a WebDAV client, which I hereby 
would like to offer for consideration to be included in Tcllib.

The README is at:
    http://www.equi4.com/pub/sk/davkit.kit/lib/webdav/README
There is a starkit at:
    http://www.equi4.com/pub/sk/davkit.kit
(it's also in sdarchive)

The code consists of two packages:

 - webdav is a client which supports a number of functions,
    as described here:
        http://www.equi4.com/pub/sk/davkit.kit/lib/webdav/
webdav.html

 - davvfs is a VFS driver which uses the webdav package

Webdav requires tclxml to parse the XML returned by WebDAV 
server (the trivial XML that is sent is done in plain Tcl).  The client 
becomes considerably faster when a compiled version of expat is 
present, but TclXML will fall back to pure Tcl just fine on any 
platform.

Davvfs is a driver which supercedes the webdavvfs client in TclVFS.  
That client was a proof of concept, and only supports read-only use 
of webdav, while these to packages support r/w, globs, stats, mkdir, 
rmdir, etc.

The current code does not support locking or versioning.  It also is 
relatively simple right now, because a read is done entirely on open 
and a write on close.  A refinement would be to pass channels 
around so I/O can be done more gradually, and progress statusbars 
could be supported.

This code was written for a commercial project, and not taken 
further than its current (startup) requirements.  It has been used 
with Apache as WebDAV server, and has been used quite a bit 
already.  The code can be placed under a Tcl- or MIT-license.

There are test suites, but these are a bit cumbersome because they 
depend on a hardwired server with specific content (test content is 
included in the starkit).

I think this set of packages would be a useful addition to tcllib, but 
a few issues will need to be resolved to do this:
 - is it ok to depend on a pure-tcl non-tcllib package? (TclXML)
 - if not, are there alternatives? the parsing demands are not high
 - should davvfs go here on in TclVFS?
W.r.t. that last point, I think it would be better to include VFS 
drivers here.  TclVFS will probably at some point become part of the 
core, or tightly bundled with it - not all possible drivers would be 
included I suspect (to allow them to be developed further, and 
because not everyone needs them all).

I'm ok with whatever the tcllib maintainers decide.  Just wanted to 
try and find a good home for this code...

-jcw
User Comments: kennykb added on 2011-09-30 01:09:01:
From the Tcl'ers Chat today (times UTC-0400):

[13:18]<siyb>is jcw available by any chance?
[13:19]kbkHe isn't often in the room, but he answers email. Can someone else help?
...
[13:19]<siyb>kbk: it's about his davkit implementation. i was looking for a source version if one is available
[13:21]<siyb>kbk: do you know if his email is still up to date ([email protected])
[13:22]   * kbk would have to check contact information at http://jeelabs.org/ - but hold on...
[13:23]kbkdavkit is available as a starkit at http://tcl.tk/starkits/
[13:23]kbkI just did an 'sdx unwrap'...
[13:24]kbkand I found a bunch of Tcl code, and then...
[13:24]kbk... native code in the Tclxml and Tclexpat packages...
[13:24]kbk... both of which are readily available in source form.
[13:24]kbkSo it looks as if downloading and unwrapping the starkit gives you all the pieces.
[13:24]<siyb>thanks 
...
[13:34]akuWe should possibly still ask jcw if he would be willing to put the sources up on github
[13:36]kbkMaybe... didn't the 'webdav' package get added to Tcllib at some point? That's really all that the kit is: webdav + dependencies (base64, Tclexpat, Tclxml, and uri)
[13:37]akuHm. Let me check ...
[13:38]akuNo, no webdav in tcllib
[13:58]kbkhttp://wiki.tcl.tk/13480 says, "The webdav and davvfs packages have been submitted to Tcllib for consideration, review, and possible inclusion."
[13:58]kbkso it's obvious what Jean-Claude's intention was.
[13:58]akuHm.
[13:59]akuI don't remember that. I'll have a look through the bug database ...
[13:59]kbkSuspicion: does the XML stuff (expat+tclxml) always require native code, and if so, did that cause a rejection?
[14:00]akuIMHO should not. (Even if would prefer tDOM)
[14:01]akufound it, assigned to Pat - 1115865
[14:06]kbksiyb - Looks as if we dropped the ball about 6.5 years ago, but we're picking it up again. Better late than never.

jcw added on 2005-02-04 07:50:55:
Logged In: YES 
user_id=1983

Forgot to mention that the webdav package relies on a modified httpd 
package (mods by Vinde Darley and Pat Thoyts AFAICT, included in the 
starkit) to support DAV requests.  There is incomplete support for HTTP/
1.1 in there, which would probably speed up the case of lots of back-to-
back requests.