TIP 373: Improved Yielding Support for Coroutines

Author:         Miguel Sofer <[email protected]>
State:          Withdrawn
Type:           Project
Vote:           Pending
Created:        12-Aug-2010
Keywords:       coroutine,yield
Obsoletes:      372
Obsoleted-By:	375
Tcl-Version:    8.6


This TIP proposes two new commands that improve control over the yielding behaviour of coroutines.


The new command yieldto allows a coroutine to suspend its execution and tailcall into an arbitrary command. It provides support for symmetric coroutines, simply specifying that the new command be another coroutine's resume command.

The new command yieldset specifies the number of arguments that the coroutine's resume command will accept. Note that yieldset obsoletes [372], in the sense that it provides a different way of satisfying the same needs.

Detailed Rationale for "yieldto"

The current yield and proposed yieldm suspend a coroutine and return the control to the coroutine's caller: they implement asymmetric coroutines.

It is well known that symmetric and asymmetric coroutines have equal power, in that each can be implemented on top of the other. In Tcl8.6 as of today, symmetric coroutines can be implemented by coding a scheduler, which may but doesn't have to use the event loop. The new command yieldto implements symmetric coroutines directly.

The ability of yieldto to yield to an arbitrary command also provides new possibilities. For instance, it allows to return a non-ok code to the caller without terminating the coroutine:

 yieldto return -level 0 -code 1 ERROR

Proposal for "yieldto"

The new command

yieldto cmd ?arg1 ...?


  1. the currently executing coroutine to suspend its execution (yield),

  2. the command built from the arguments to yieldto, as resolved in the coroutine's context, is run in the coroutine's caller scope,

  3. from the point of view of the coroutine's caller, the return value and options of the new command is what the coroutine returned on yielding.

In other words, yieldto implements "suspend yourself and tailcall the new command"; yieldto is to yield as tailcall is to return.

Implementation of "yieldto"

Simply rename the ::tcl::unsupported::yieldTo into the global namespace while getting rid of the camelCase, and extend the coroutine documentation and test-suite to refer to the new command.

Rationale and Proposal for "yieldset"

[372] justifies and requests a different interface to a coroutine's resume command, allowing for an arbitrary number of arguments that shall be returned to the coroutine's body in a list.

In order to limit the number of additional commands (yieldm and also yieldmto), and increase the flexibility, it is proposed to add a command:

yieldset ?arglist?

that sets the acceptable arguments for the resume command.

If yieldset is called with no arguments it returns the current list of arguments.

If yieldset is called with a list argument, it specifies the arguments to the resume command in the manner of proc. The argument names shall only be used for the error message if the resume command is called with an invalid number of arguments.

In this manner, current yield behaves as if

 yieldset {{arg {}}}

had been called. This shall remain the default behaviour.

If yieldset is called outside of a coroutine context, it sets the default behaviour for newly created coroutines. If it is called within a coroutine context it sets the behaviour for the current coroutine only.

In order to obtain [372]'s yieldm behaviour for yield, it would be necessary to call:

 yieldset args

either before creating the coroutine or else within the coroutine body.

The default arglist shall be {{arg {}}}, so that the current yield is the default behaviour. The arglist value can be changed with yieldset at any time, and remains valid until changed again.


Some new proposals for better coroutine interfaces are being discussed, based on ensembles and providing additional functionality.

I do not foresee the discussion to settle in the immediate future. The current TIP is not meant to preempt any such design, it just attempts to provide a limited improvement that is easy to implement immediately.


This document has been placed in the public domain.