TclTLS
History Of Ticket 006bd0c74e0a21fa
Login
HomeTimelineDownloadBrowse SourceBranchesTagsTicketsWiki
Check-ins Status Timeline

Artifacts Associated With Ticket 006bd0c74e0a21fa

  1. Ticket change [3d971a41a9] (rid 1585) by ssteidl on 2022-11-07 02:06:34:

    1. foundin initialized to: "1.8.0"
    2. icomment: 
      BIO_CTRL_PUSH is an optional value that is not handled in the tlsBIO:BioCtrl(). 

The larger problem is that the library does not support new optional commands because it returns -2 for unknown cmds in BioCtrl().  I would suggest changing the default return value to 0.  I confirmed that this fixed the issue.  

*tcltls version*: 1.8.0 (trunk as of today) 
*OS*: FreeBSD 12.3
*Openssl version*: 1.1.1q

Patch
=====

```
--- tlsBIO.c
+++ tlsBIO.c
@@ -279,11 +279,11 @@
 			ret = ((Tcl_WriteRaw(chan, "", 0) >= 0) ? 1 : -1);
 			dprintf("BIO_CTRL_FLUSH returning value %li", ret);
 			break;
 		default:
 			dprintf("Got unknown control command (%i)", cmd);
-			ret = -2;
+            ret = 0;
 			break;
 	}
 
 	return(ret);
 }

```

Example of problem
==================
```
package require tls   
./tls.c:1785:Tls_Init():Called
./tls.c:1903:TlsLibInit():Called
./tlsBIO.c:53:BIO_new_tcl():BIO_new_tcl() called
./tlsBIO.c:66:BIO_new_tcl():Asked to setup a NULL state, just creating the initial configuration
1.8.0
% set sock [tls::socket listener.logz.io 5052]
./tls.c:759:ImportObjCmd():Called
./tls.c:1093:CTX_Init():Called
./tls.c:925:ImportObjCmd():Consuming Tcl channel sock8010d2690
./tls.c:927:ImportObjCmd():Created channel named sock8010d2690
./tlsIO.c:699:TlsWatchProc():TlsWatchProc(0x0)
./tlsIO.c:708:TlsWatchProc():statePtr->flags=0|TLS_TCL_INIT
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsIO.c:734:TlsWatchProc():Registering our interest in the lower channel (chan=0x80105e050)
./tlsIO.c:699:TlsWatchProc():TlsWatchProc(0x0)
./tlsIO.c:708:TlsWatchProc():statePtr->flags=0|TLS_TCL_INIT
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsIO.c:734:TlsWatchProc():Registering our interest in the lower channel (chan=0x80105e050)
./tlsBIO.c:53:BIO_new_tcl():BIO_new_tcl() called
./tlsBIO.c:292:BioNew():BioNew(0x80092f680) called
./tls.c:991:ImportObjCmd():Returning sock8010d2690
sock8010d2690
% tls::handshake $sock
./tls.c:647:HandshakeObjCmd():Called
./tls.c:669:HandshakeObjCmd():Calling Tls_WaitForConnect
./tlsIO.c:197:Tls_WaitForConnect():WaitForConnect(0x80107c010)
./tlsIO.c:198:Tls_WaitForConnect():statePtr->flags=0|TLS_TCL_INIT
./tlsIO.c:228:Tls_WaitForConnect():Calling SSL_connect()
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:229:BioCtrl():BioCtrl(0x80092f680, 0x6, 0x0, 0x80092f780)
./tlsBIO.c:283:BioCtrl():Got unknown control command (6)
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:120:BioWrite():[chan=0x80105e050] BioWrite(0x80092f680, <buf>, 517)
./tlsBIO.c:127:BioWrite():[chan=0x80105e050] BioWrite(517) -> 517 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:148:BioWrite():Successfully wrote some data
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:229:BioCtrl():BioCtrl(0x80092f680, 0xb, 0x0, 0x0)
./tlsBIO.c:278:BioCtrl():Got BIO_CTRL_FLUSH
./tlsBIO.c:280:BioCtrl():BIO_CTRL_FLUSH returning value 1
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 122)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(122) -> 122 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 122) [0x80105e050] returning 122
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 1)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(1) -> 1 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 1) [0x80105e050] returning 1
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 23)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(23) -> 23 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 23) [0x80105e050] returning 23
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5673)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5673) -> 5673 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5673) [0x80105e050] returning 5673
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tls.c:283:VerifyCallback():Verify: 0
./tls.c:283:VerifyCallback():Verify: 1
./tls.c:283:VerifyCallback():Verify: 1
./tls.c:283:VerifyCallback():Verify: 1
./tls.c:283:VerifyCallback():Verify: 1
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 281)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(281) -> 281 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 281) [0x80105e050] returning 281
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(5) -> 5 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 5) [0x80105e050] returning 5
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:169:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 69)
./tlsBIO.c:180:BioRead():[chan=0x80105e050] BioRead(69) -> 69 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:201:BioRead():Successfully read some data
./tlsBIO.c:212:BioRead():BioRead(0x80092f680, <buf>, 69) [0x80105e050] returning 69
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:120:BioWrite():[chan=0x80105e050] BioWrite(0x80092f680, <buf>, 80)
./tlsBIO.c:127:BioWrite():[chan=0x80105e050] BioWrite(80) -> 80 [tclEof=0; tclErrno=0]
./tlsBIO.c:148:BioWrite():Successfully wrote some data
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:229:BioCtrl():BioCtrl(0x80092f680, 0xb, 0x0, 0x0)
./tlsBIO.c:278:BioCtrl():Got BIO_CTRL_FLUSH
./tlsBIO.c:280:BioCtrl():BIO_CTRL_FLUSH returning value 1
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:229:BioCtrl():BioCtrl(0x80092f680, 0x7, 0x0, 0x80092f780)
./tlsBIO.c:283:BioCtrl():Got unknown control command (7)
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tls.c:180:InfoCallback():Called
./tlsIO.c:234:Tls_WaitForConnect():That seems to have gone okay
./tlsIO.c:972:Tls_GetParent():Requested to get parent of channel 0x801085090
./tlsBIO.c:229:BioCtrl():BioCtrl(0x80092f680, 0xb, 0x0, 0x0)
./tlsBIO.c:278:BioCtrl():Got BIO_CTRL_FLUSH
./tlsBIO.c:280:BioCtrl():BIO_CTRL_FLUSH returning value 1
./tlsIO.c:245:Tls_WaitForConnect():Got error: 1 (rc = 0)
./tlsIO.c:278:Tls_WaitForConnect():We have either completely established the session or completely failed it -- there is no more need to ever retry it though
./tlsIO.c:288:Tls_WaitForConnect():The connection is up
./tlsIO.c:348:Tls_WaitForConnect():Removing the "TLS_TCL_INIT" flag since we have completed the handshake
./tlsIO.c:351:Tls_WaitForConnect():Returning in success
./tls.c:671:HandshakeObjCmd():Tls_WaitForConnect returned: 0
./tls.c:699:HandshakeObjCmd():Returning TCL_OK with data "1"
```
    3. login: "ssteidl"
    4. mimetype: "text/x-markdown"
    5. private_contact initialized to: "dde1eb0bdf6f54ba2c9e6ea72e4617520b3c7b1b"
    6. severity initialized to: "Severe"
    7. status initialized to: "Open"
    8. title initialized to: "PATCH: BIO_CTRL_PUSH not handled"
    9. type initialized to: "Code Defect"

  2. Ticket change [579f872175] (rid 1592) by gustafn3 on 2023-10-22 09:40:24:

    1. icomment: 
      Ignoring all unknown controls is not a good idea. 

Since not all OpenSSL versions and variants support "BIO_CTRL_POP" and "BIO_CTRL_PUSH", the following is change is a more proper patch.

This was tested with Tcl 8.6.13, tcltls-1.7.22 and OpenSSL 3.1.3 (19 Sep 2023).


````
--- tlsBIO.c-orig	2023-10-21 17:38:57
+++ tlsBIO.c	2023-10-22 11:32:02
@@ -278,7 +278,15 @@
 			dprintf("Got BIO_CTRL_FLUSH");
 			ret = ((Tcl_WriteRaw(chan, "", 0) >= 0) ? 1 : -1);
 			dprintf("BIO_CTRL_FLUSH returning value %li", ret);
+			break;
+#ifdef BIO_CTRL_POP
+                case BIO_CTRL_POP:
+                        dprintf("Got BIO_CTRL_POP");
+                        break;
+                case BIO_CTRL_PUSH:
+                        dprintf("Got BIO_CTRL_PUSH");
 			break;
+#endif
 		default:
 			dprintf("Got unknown control command (%i)", cmd);
 			ret = -2;
````
    2. login: "gustafn3"
    3. mimetype: "text/x-markdown"
    4. priority changed to: "Immediate"
    5. resolution changed to: "Open"

  3. Ticket change [4b5f684820] (rid 1789) by jan.nijtmans on 2024-02-22 17:47:13:

    1. icomment: "Fixed [1b8c76f783|here]"
    2. login: "jan.nijtmans"
    3. mimetype: "text/x-markdown"
    4. resolution changed to: "Fixed"
    5. status changed to: "Closed"

  4. Ticket change [390db77fda] (rid 3553) by bohagan on 2024-05-28 00:20:10:

    1. icomment: "Fixed in [602c39a56cdd7856]"
    2. login: "bohagan"
    3. mimetype: "text/x-fossil-plain"
Powered by Fossil · RSS