Tcl Source Code

View Ticket
Login
Ticket UUID: 1758527
Title: env bug on platform windows
Type: Bug Created on: 2007-07-22 18:08:34
Submitter: exgerhardr Assigned to: jan.nijtmans
Subsystem: 08. Environment Variables Severity: Minor
Priority: 5 Medium Last modified: 2026-10-22 17:19:29
Status: Closed Closed by: serhiy.storchaka
Resolution: Duplicate Closed on: 2026-10-21 09:58:25
Version: None
Description:
test procedure:
-----------------------------------------
% set env(Test) "Value"
Value
% info exists env(Test)
1
% puts $env(Test)
Value
% set env(Test) ""
% info exists env(Test)
1
% puts $env(Test)
can't read "env(Test)": no such variable
-----------------------------------------

[info exists ..] returns 1 but the variable cannot be dereferenced.

% puts $tcl_patchLevel
8.4.13
% parray tcl_platform
tcl_platform(byteOrder) = littleEndian
tcl_platform(machine)   = intel
tcl_platform(os)        = Windows NT
tcl_platform(osVersion) = 5.0
tcl_platform(platform)  = windows

Same on Windows XP (Windows NT 5.1) with TCL 8.4.11,
no problem on Linux and Unix (AIX), "" is returned.

additional infos from comp.lang.tcl
========================================
 Still stranger: when you do an "array names env" before "info exists
env(Test)" it vanishes in TCL.

(bin) 38 % info patchlevel
8.4.13
(bin) 39 % set env(Test) "X"
X
(bin) 40 % info exists env(Test)
1
(bin) 41 % set env(Test) ""
(bin) 42 % info exists env(Test)
1
(bin) 43 % array names env
HOME PROCESSOR_IDENTIFIER ComSpec DEVMGR_SHOW_DETAILS
DEVMGR_SHOW_NONPRESENT_DEVICES JSERV HOMEDRIVE ALLUSERSPROFILE
FP_NO_HOST_CHECK SESSIONNAME PROCESSOR_REVISION PATHEXT LOGONSERVER
VS80COMNTOOLS USERDOMAIN PROCESSOR_LEVEL DEFAULT_CA_NR USERPROFILE
USERNAME COMPUTERNAME TREECTRL_LIBRARY TMP SystemRoot
PROCESSOR_ARCHITECTURE OS ProgramFiles APPDATA CommonProgramFiles
WV_GATEWAY_CFG windir Path TEMP HOMEPATH VU_LIBRARY SystemDrive
PERL5LIB NUMBER_OF_PROCESSORS
(bin) 44 % info exists env(Test)
0
(bin) 45 %
========================================
So it seems that [array names] does some magic when the array in
question is 'env' - namely unsetting the internal 'env' array and then
re-populating it by asking Windows for all existing environment
variables - et voilĂ  they're both in sync again.
User Comments:
hobbs added on 2008-01-14 08:01:26:
Logged In: YES 
user_id=72656
Originator: NO

This problem is rooted in Windows magic handling of setting an env var to "" to mean unsetting it.

davygrvy added on 2008-01-18 07:08:40:
Logged In: YES 
user_id=7549
Originator: NO

Like Jeff says, empty is unfortunately unset on win, too, which due to (possibly over agressive) internal array caching leaves Tcl thinking it's still there.

Kinda reminds me of the file case issue where 'Readme.txt' is still the same file as 'readme.txt' which makes programs like CVS have a cow when the repository is hosted on a unix box where the two filenames are different files and the client is on win trying to overwrite and complaining about it: 'C move Readme.txt, it is in the way'.

Jeff, is it possible that the internal caching could be bypassed for more accurate results?

Busirane added on 2020-04-30 16:12:02:
Is this the same bug? The result changes with every other invocation. 
The same thing happens with C?????? for COMSPEC and ComSpec. Notably, Path 
and ComSpec are the two environment variables that are supposed to get 
special treatment on Windows, by being uppercased. This causes problems with 
tcltest 2.4.0 when cleanupTests tries to restore the environment array.

(Desktop) 1 % array names env P???
PATH Path
(Desktop) 2 % array names env P???
PATH
(Desktop) 3 % array names env P???
PATH Path
(Desktop) 4 % array names env P???
PATH
(Desktop) 5 % info patchlevel
8.6.6
(Desktop) 6 % parray tcl_platform
tcl_platform(byteOrder)     = littleEndian
tcl_platform(engine)        = Tcl
tcl_platform(machine)       = intel
tcl_platform(os)            = Windows NT
tcl_platform(osVersion)     = 10.0
tcl_platform(pathSeparator) = ;
tcl_platform(platform)      = windows
tcl_platform(pointerSize)   = 4
tcl_platform(threaded)      = 1
tcl_platform(user)          = HTSP1395
tcl_platform(wordSize)      = 4

jan.nijtmans added on 2020-06-21 17:17:18:

I think this one is fixed already, but I'll double-check


jan.nijtmans added on 2020-07-08 14:55:24:

No, it's not fixed:

>tclsh86.exe
% set env(Test) "Value"
Value
% info exists env(Test)
1
% puts $env(Test)
Value
% set env(Test) ""
% info exists env(Test)
1
% puts $env(Test)
can't read "env(Test)": no such variable

It looks like - on Windows - setting an environment variable to the empty string is the same as removing the environment variable. Not sure what we can do about this


jan.nijtmans added on 2020-07-08 14:59:04:

The other reported strange behavior is gone:

% array names env P???
PATH
% array names env P???
PATH
% array names env P???
PATH


serhiy.storchaka added on 2026-10-21 09:58:25:

Duplicate of [b492c33154], fixed in 9.0.4 and 9.1.0 by [8e0656d976] / [2ae307305b]: on Windows, setting an env element to "" now removes it from the array too. 8.6 is unchanged.