Tcl Source Code

View Ticket
Login
Ticket UUID: 1228806
Title: Enhance '-verbose s' so that '-skip'ped tests are reported
Type: RFE Created on: 2005-06-28 06:53:06
Submitter: mpettigr Assigned to: dgp
Subsystem: 34. tcltest Package Severity: Minor
Priority: 5 Medium Last modified: 2026-06-26 05:39:53
Status: Open Closed by: nobody
Resolution: None Closed on:
Version: None
Description:
Currently tests skipped from the command-line are not 
reported when '-verbose s' is set, only skipped tests due 
to constraints are reported.  For example,

tclsh all.tcl -verbose s -skip foo*

will not report any skipped tests except in summary.  
This new feature is also convenient because it allows a 
way to list the test names from the command-line, e.g.,

tclsh all.tcl -verbose s -skip *

possible solution:

Update Skipped proc when the following code.  Note: 
patch begin and end comments where patch is inserted 
below.

proc tcltest::Skipped {name constraints} {
    variable testLevel
    variable numTests
    variable testConstraints

    if {$testLevel == 1} {
incr numTests(Total)
    }
    # skip the test if it's name matches an element of skip
    foreach pattern [skip] {
if {[string match $pattern $name]} {
    if {$testLevel == 1} {
incr numTests(Skipped)
DebugDo 1 
{AddToSkippedBecause userSpecifiedSkip}
    }
  # MNP - patch begin
    if {[IsVerbose skip]} {
puts [outputChannel] "++++ 
$name SKIPPED: userSpecifiedSkip"
    }
  # MNP - patch end
    return 1
}
    }
User Comments:
juliannoble2 added on 2026-06-26 05:39:53:
After 20+ years of this behaviour, It may not be worth the risk of changing this due to compatibility concerns - but the documentation could be clearer here.
Currently the documentation is very vague regarding the -verbose setting:

  skip (s)
  Print output when a test is skipped

The ++++ <testname> SKIPPED: <constraint/reason> output seems to be missing also when there is no positive match for the -match flag.

A note that the -verbose skip value only refers to constraints, whilst summary "SKIP" values are more comprehensive would be good.