Tcl Source Code

View Ticket
Login
2026-10-19
18:44 • Ticket [3183016fff] cd .. from link in Windows confuses Tcl status still Ope... artifact: 616cef19e5 user: serhiy.storchaka
18:44 • Ticket [3577801fff] Issue with file normalize on Linux with symlink wtih &quot... artifact: 36b590b922 user: serhiy.storchaka
18:37
Fix [3577801fff], [3570244fff], [3183016fff] and [3099612fff]: on Unix, [file normalize] and [cd ..]... leaf check-in: 854be12c0a user: serhiy.storchaka tags: normalize-dotdot-after-link
2011-09-12
02:01 • Ticket [3183016fff] cd .. from link in Windows confuses Tcl status still Ope... artifact: 1823a36aa2 user: guardus
01:10 • Ticket [3183016fff]: 4 changes artifact: daa9086a1b user: dgp
01:09 • Ticket [3183016fff]: 4 changes artifact: a2ed9ba29f user: dgp
2011-09-11
00:17 • Ticket [3183016fff]: 5 changes artifact: a8636f4950 user: guardus
2011-02-16
08:03 • Add attachment error.tcl to ticket [3183016fff] artifact: 3993ef5698 user: guardus
08:03 • Ticket [3183016fff] cd .. from link in Windows confuses Tcl status still Ope... artifact: 13478cfe66 user: guardus
01:03 • New ticket [3183016fff]. artifact: 9da9c5c59d user: guardus

Ticket UUID: 3183016
Title: cd .. from link in Windows confuses Tcl
Type: Bug Created on: 2011-02-16 01:03:24
Submitter: guardus Assigned to: vincentdarley
Subsystem: 36. Pathname Management Severity:
Priority: 5 Medium Last modified: 2026-10-19 18:44:30
Status: Open Closed by:
Resolution: None Closed on:
Version: 8.6.18, 9.0.5, 9.1.0
Description:
OS: Windows XP SP3

Performing "cd .." from a link confuses Tcl.

To recreate:
  1. Create directory test1 and subdirectory test1/test2 and then create a link in test2 to test1.
  2. cd test1/test2/<link>
  3. cd ..
  4. pwd and glob reports as if in parent of test1, but "file exists" finds file in test2 and cd acts as if in test2.

See attached Tcl script.
User Comments:
guardus added on 2011-02-16 08:03:24:

File Added - 401787: error.tcl

guardus added on 2011-09-11 00:17:59:
Same issue in ActiveTcl 8.5.10.1.

dgp added on 2011-09-12 01:09:38:
Please review ticket 961646
and comment whether this is a
new issue distinct from that, or a
duplicate report of the same issue.
Thanks.

dgp added on 2011-09-12 01:10:33:
If you could also report whether any
release of Tcl since 8.4.0 met your
expectations on the same platform,
that would be useful info.

guardus added on 2011-09-12 02:01:58:
I could not find 961646, but I did find 849514, and this certainly seems to be similar to 849514.

I don't have 8.4 on my system.

serhiy.storchaka added on 2026-10-19 18:44:30:

Still present on Windows 11 with 8.5.19 to 9.1: after cd test1/test2/link; cd .. with a junction to test1, [pwd] and [glob] show the parent of test1, while [file exists], [open] and cmd /c cd use test2. Tcl resolves ".." physically after the link, but Windows itself resolves it lexically.

Proposed fix in branch normalize-dotdot-after-link: on Windows ".." is resolved lexically, as the system does (and as Python's ntpath.realpath() does), so all of them agree on test2; links elsewhere in the path are still resolved. This works for junctions and for mklink /D symbolic links, absolute or relative. Potential incompatibility: [file normalize junction/..] is now the parent of the junction, not of its target; filesystem-1.26 and 1.28 are changed accordingly. On Unix ".." stays physical, and a trailing ".." after a relative link is now resolved ([3577801fff]). Tests winFile-6.1, 6.2 and filesystem-1.57.


Attachments: